Hari Shankar Tibrewala

Governance is the cheapest due diligence

The cheapest check I know costs nothing: watch what management does when nobody is watching the share price.

Spreadsheets are expensive. Lawyers are more expensive. The cheapest piece of due diligence I know costs nothing at all: watch how the people in charge behave when they think it does not matter.

I have looked at a lot of companies, listed and unlisted, in India, the Gulf and Europe. The numbers differ every time. The warning signs are remarkably loyal. They turn up in the same places, wearing the same clothes.

Do the small things arrive on time?

Accounts filed late. Board minutes that appear three months after the meeting. A data room where half the folders are empty and the other half are called “final_v7”.

None of this proves anything is wrong. But a company that cannot manage a filing deadline is asking me to trust it with something much harder, which is my capital. I have learned to take the hint.

Who can say no to the founder?

Every good business I have owned had at least one person who could tell the boss he was wrong and still have a job on Monday. Sometimes it was a finance head. Sometimes an independent director who actually read the papers.

When nobody can say no, the company does not have governance. It has a mood.

Where does the money go between the company and its owners?

Related-party transactions are not automatically a problem. Family businesses built half the economies I invest in. But I want them few, explained and priced as if a stranger were on the other side. If the explanation needs a diagram, I usually stop reading.

How do they give bad news?

This is the question I weigh most. Anyone can write a cheerful update in a good quarter. I look for the letter written after a bad one. Did it arrive early or late? Did it say “we got this wrong” or “market conditions”?

Management that tells me bad news quickly is giving me something valuable: time to think. Management that hides it is borrowing my trust at a rate of interest I cannot afford.

Why this matters more in private deals

In listed markets, a daily price does some of the policing for you. It is a noisy policeman, but it is there. In an unlisted deal there is no price to hide behind and none to warn you. Information quality and aligned incentives are the whole game. I am stricter there, not because private founders are worse, but because my exits are fewer.

My short list

  • Filings, audits and minutes arrive on time, without being chased.
  • At least one person can overrule the founder, and has.
  • Related-party dealings are few, disclosed and sensibly priced.
  • Bad news comes early and in plain words.

None of these will tell you what a business is worth. They tell you whether the valuation you worked so hard on will still mean anything in five years. A cheap share in a badly run company is not a bargain. It is a subscription to surprises.