Hari Shankar Tibrewala

How I read an annual report

I read annual reports back to front, with a pencil, and slightly suspicious of the photographs. This is the order I use.

Most people read an annual report the way the company hopes they will: from the front. Smiling chairman, rising chart, a photograph of a wind turbine whether or not the company owns one.

I start at the back. The front of the report is what the company wants me to feel. The back is what it is obliged to tell me.

First, the notes

The notes to the accounts are where the interesting things live, mostly because few people visit. I look for three: contingent liabilities, related-party transactions and any change in accounting policy.

A change in policy is not a crime. But if profits improved in the same year the method of counting them changed, I would like to know which of the two did the work.

Then, the cash

Profit is an opinion. Cash is closer to a fact. I put the profit figure next to the cash generated from operations and compare them over several years, not one.

If a business reports healthy profits year after year while cash keeps failing to turn up, somebody is being optimistic. It might be the customers, who have not paid. It might be the accountants. Either way, I would rather find out before I own the shares.

Then, what they did with it

Capital allocation is the part of management’s job that compounds. Did the cash go into the core business, into acquisitions, back to shareholders, or into something described as “strategic”?

I am wary of the word strategic. In my experience it often means “we could not make the numbers work, so we changed the subject”.

Then, the auditor

I read the audit report in full, which takes four minutes and is skipped by nearly everyone. I check who the auditor is, how long they have been there and whether anything is flagged as a key matter. A sudden change of auditor is worth a question. Two in three years is worth several.

Only then, the chairman’s letter

By now I know roughly what happened. So I read the letter to see whether the chairman knows too. The best letters match the notes. They mention what went wrong before I have to find it.

I also read last year’s letter beside this year’s. Promises are easy to make. They are more revealing twelve months later.

What I am really looking for

  • Do the cash flows agree with the profits over time?
  • Is the balance sheet simpler or more complicated than five years ago?
  • Does management explain its mistakes without being asked?
  • Would I understand how this company makes money if the photographs were removed?

None of this needs a finance degree. It needs an afternoon, a pencil and a willingness to read the boring pages. That is where the returns hide, and they are rarely disturbed.